🌊 Cedar Lake, Indiana Neighborhood Guide
Your Local REALTOR® Guide to Living in Cedar Lake
By Holly Brumm Furdo, Better Homes & Gardens Real Estate Connections
🏡 Is Cedar Lake, Indiana a Good Place to Live?
Yes — Cedar Lake is one of the fastest-growing and most exciting places to live in Northwest Indiana thanks to its gorgeous 794-acre lake, booming new construction, affordable neighborhoods, and laid-back lifestyle.
If you want a community that feels like “lake life meets small-town charm,” Cedar Lake is one of the best places to consider.
❤️ Who Cedar Lake Is Perfect For
✔ Buyers who want lake living without Michigan prices
✔ Families looking for quiet neighborhoods + good schools
✔ People wanting new construction or move-in-ready homes
✔ Buyers looking for affordability compared to Crown Point or St. John
✔ Those who want outdoor recreation, boating, kayaking, or walking trails
✔ Buyers wanting a relaxed, friendly, community-oriented vibe
⭐ Best Neighborhoods in Cedar Lake
Below are the Cedar Lake neighborhoods and communities buyers ask me about most — including lifestyle details, price ranges, and who they tend to fit best.
1. Lakeside (North + South)
Best for: Lake lovers, boaters, families
Vibe: Waterfront views, charming streets, mix of updated and older homes
The Lakeside areas offer some of the closest access to the water, making them favorites for anyone who loves boating, fishing, or sunsets on the lake. Homes range from classic cottages to beautifully remodeled properties.
Why buyers love it:
-
Walkable to lake access
-
Lakefront charm
-
Beautiful sunrises & sunsets
-
Mix of affordable + upgraded homes
2. Beacon Pointe
Best for: Families, new construction buyers
Vibe: Modern, clean, newer subdivision with great layouts
Beacon Pointe offers beautiful new construction homes with sidewalks, parks, ponds, and a friendly neighborhood feel. It’s ideal for buyers wanting modern designs and open-concept living.
Why buyers love it:
-
Newer homes + up-to-date finishes
-
Great curb appeal
-
Sidewalks and ponds
-
Strong resale value
3. Summer Winds
Best for: Modern buyers wanting value + convenience
Vibe: Fresh, new, and community-focused
Summer Winds is a newer community perfect for buyers looking for a clean, bright subdivision that feels both modern and affordable.
Why buyers love it:
-
Contemporary homes
-
Affordable new construction
-
Close to both Cedar Lake and Crown Point amenities
4. Havenwood / Centennial
Best for: Buyers who want established homes with larger yards
Vibe: Mature, quiet, friendly, great value
These neighborhoods offer well-maintained homes on nice-sized lots, making them popular with families and buyers who want space without breaking the budget.
Why buyers love it:
-
Larger yards
-
Mature landscaping
-
Quiet streets
-
Affordable options
5. Lakeside Meadows
Best for: First-time buyers + move-up buyers
Vibe: Peaceful, clean, and community-oriented
Lakeside Meadows combines affordability with a newer, well-kept neighborhood feel.
Why buyers love it:
-
Great value
-
Walkable streets
-
Close to the lake
-
Modern layouts
6. The Preserve
Best for: Buyers wanting upscale, newer homes
Vibe: Elegant, quiet, nature-focused
The Preserve offers gorgeous newer construction homes with a beautiful natural setting. If you want something higher-end but not luxury-priced, this is a great option.
Why buyers love it:
-
Scenic environment
-
Upscale designs
-
Private and peaceful
🧭 What It’s Like to Live in Cedar Lake
✨ Lifestyle & Vibe
Cedar Lake feels like a getaway without actually being away.
It’s:
-
Relaxed
-
Friendly
-
Outdoorsy
-
Community-centered
-
Perfect for “lake people”
It feels slower-paced than Crown Point and St. John — in a good way.
🏫 Schools
Cedar Lake is served primarily by:
-
Crown Point Community Schools (in some areas)
Hanover Schools are known for small class sizes and a strong community feel.
🛍 Shopping & Dining
Cedar Lake continues to grow with new restaurants and businesses.
Local favorites include:
Cedar Lake is also close to Crown Point’s shopping, dining, and downtown events.
🚗 Commute
Cedar Lake offers quick access to:
-
Route 231
-
Route 41
-
Crown Point
-
St. John
-
Lowell
Depending on your location, you can reach major employers and interstates in minutes.
🌳 Parks, Recreation & Lake Life
This is where Cedar Lake shines.
Residents enjoy:
Summer on the lake is a big perk of living here — it’s beautiful, fun, and feels like a vacation in your backyard.
👍 Pros and Cons of Living in Cedar Lake
PROS
-
Beautiful lake and outdoor activities
-
Affordable compared to other NWI towns
-
Lots of new construction
-
Quiet, peaceful lifestyle
-
Good schools
-
Strong community feel
CONS
-
Limited walkability outside lake areas
-
Some older homes require updates
-
Growing quickly → increased traffic in summer
-
Fewer big-box stores (but close to Crown Point)
💬 Real Talk from Holly
My Cedar Lake buyers almost always tell me:
-
“We love being near the water.”
-
“It feels like a breath of fresh air.”
-
“It’s quieter than Crown Point — in a good way.”
-
“We didn’t realize we could get this much house for the price.”
Cedar Lake is perfect for people who want beauty + space + affordability all in one place.
❓ Frequently Asked Questions
Are home prices lower in Cedar Lake?
Yes — it’s one of the more affordable towns in NWI.
Is Cedar Lake good for families?
Absolutely — great schools + quiet neighborhoods.
Is Cedar Lake a good place for new construction?
Yes — lots of new developments and modern homes.
Is lake access available?
Yes — both public and private options depending on the area.
Are the schools good?
Hanover Schools are popular for their community feel and class size. Some areas feed into Crown Point Schools.
📲 Thinking About Cedar Lake? Let’s Explore It Together.
Whether you want lake access, new construction, or a peaceful neighborhood, I’d love to help you compare Cedar Lake with Crown Point, St. John, Schererville, and Lowell.
Call or text me anytime at 219-313-0692
or visit https://hollybrummfurdo.com to browse homes and resources.
